Google Could Take 2.25% Of Every iPhone Sold After Motorola Acquisition

Google Could Take 2.25% Of Every iPhone Sold After Motorola Acquisition
Google has sent letters out to various standards organizations, including the IEEE, promising to honor MMI’s patent licensing policies after it completes its planned acquisition of the company. This includes honoring MMI’s maximum go-forward per-unit royalty rate of 2.25%. This is the same rate MMI is asking Apple to pay in order to lift the injunction on the iPhone and iPad 3G passed down in Germany. Apple has rejected this offer and is fighting it, claiming it’s unfair and contrary to the principles of FRAND licensing commitments. No matter the outcome of the Apple/Motorola dispute, Google will be honoring it once they take over.

Unlike Google’s patent suing counterparts, Google has vowed to use injunctions as a last resort. This is a move we can only hope other companies adopt:

Google will make a final offer of its RAND license terms for products covered by the acquired MMI Essential Patent Claims, without prejudice to any right to recover damages for past unlicensed use. Google will make this offer before seeking injunctive relief for infringement of the acquired MMI Essential Patent Claims (i) that is the subject of litigation commenced after the date of this letter or (ii) introduced into existing litigation after the date of this letter. As described above, the offer may include a reciprocal grant back license for Google’s products to the licensee’s Essential Patent Claims for the same standards, also on RAND terms. The offer shall be open for at least 30 days, provided that the counterparty agrees not to seek injunctive relief against Google’s products based on the counterparty’s own standard essential patents reading on the same standards during that period. If the counterparty accepts Google’s RAND offer, Google will not apply for injunctive relief based on the acquired MMI Essential Patent Claims.

While you’ll most likely see this story spun to look as if Google is attacking Apple, you’ll have to first remember that the Google/Motorola acquisitions has NOT taken place yet and any licencing fee MMI asks from Apple will have occurred before Google’s acquisition. However, Google will honor any licencing fee imposed by MMI, even if that fee is the maximum 2.25%.

Apps you might like

  • Anonymous

    AND you have to promise to drop all injunctions against Google, no matter how egregious the violation.  You don’t think that’s a major part of Google’s algebra, do you?

  • Prof. Peabody

    This *is* Google attacking Apple.  The fact that the acquisition is not 100% final has nothing to do with this.

    Google specifically negotiated the right to veto/approve all legal decisions by Motorola with the purchase and reviewed this decision specifically before allowing Motorola to proceed.  

    The letters are from *Google* not Motorola and have Google’s direct and specific approval for all the tactics mentioned.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_BIUMCQV5PTJJ7K25YHVYMWZ6N4 PeterLin

    The distinction is that MMI and Samsung are using their FRAND commitments to attack Apple. And they want to charge up to 2.5% of the cost of the instrument. And they have sought an injunction as a remedy simply because Apple will not agree to their terms. Google should disavow this approach.

  • Anonymous

    This won’t go anywhere. Why does Motorola think they should get 2.25% of a devices retail cost when other companies charge a fraction of that? What makes them (or their patents) more deserving than others?

  • Anonymous

    The Google/Android phone world is completely mental and delusional if they think the rest of the industry will let them get away with this. Soon, all the various standards bodies will back tha Apple/Microsoft/Cisco proposals and leave Google holding a pencil in a knife fight they started.
    Google’s unmatched hubris is staggering.

About the author

Vincent MessinaVincent Messina has been writing and evangelizing about Android for the past three years. When he's not playing the part of "Loki" to his 5 and 4-year-old, he can be found here, covering all things Android. He adamantly believes Android has the greatest community around and can be harassed at any of the following locations: Google+, Twitter.

email hidden; JavaScript is required| Read more posts by .

Posted in Android, News, Top stories | Tagged: , , , , , |


scribol